Al-Jazeerah: Cross-Cultural Understanding
www.ccun.org www.aljazeerah.info |
Opinion Editorials, January 2020 |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Archives Mission & Name Conflict Terminology Editorials Gaza Holocaust Gulf War Isdood Islam News News Photos Opinion Editorials US Foreign Policy (Dr. El-Najjar's Articles) www.aljazeerah.info
|
Ten years ago a group of Christian Palestinians issued “a cry of hope in the absence of all hope”, reflecting their country’s decades of suffering under brutal Israeli occupation. They said they hadreached a dead end in the tragedy of the Palestinian people because international decision-makers contented themselves with “managing” the crisis rather than solving it. The situation was, and still is, destroying human life and that must surely be of concern to the church. “We call out as Christians and as Palestinians to our religious and political leaders, to our Palestinian society and to the Israeli society, to the international community, and to our Christian brothers and sisters in the churches around the world.” Questions were repeatedly asked but never answered: What is the international community doing? What are the political leaders in Palestine, in Israel and in the Arab world doing? And what is the worldwide church doing about this? What exactly is the problem?The Kairos document included a long list of key issues which described the appalling situation. This is a bullet-point summary:
It’s a serious grumble-sheet which perfectly matches my own observations during visits there. “Beyond urgent”Eight years later, in 2017, came an Open Letter from Christian Palestinians to the World Council of Churches and the ecumenical movement. It was a heart-rending cry for help from the National Coalition of Christian Organisations in Palestine (NCCOP) saying the situation for Palestinians was “beyond urgent”. churches there were asking churches everywhere to call things as they are… to tell the awful truth: that is, to recognise that Israel is an apartheid state in terms of international law and the UN reports which said so. They were concerned that states and churches were still dealing with Israel on a business-as-usual basis and ignoring the criminal reality of the military occupation. After all, the world’s churches had come together in opposition to apartheid in South Africa and helped to defeat it. Why hadn’t they done the same in Palestine? And they asked the World Council of Churches to condemn the Balfour Declaration as unjust and prod the UK into apologising and compensating the Palestinian people for their losses. Here is the link to the actual document. Its powerful message should have made genuine churchmen sit up. It reminded everyone that Palestinians were still suffering from 100 years of oppression, beginning with “the unjust and unlawful Balfour Declaration, intensified through the Nakba [ethnic cleansing and dispossession of Palestinians in 1948] and the influx of refugees, followed by the Israeli occupation of the West Bank, including East Jerusalem and Gaza and the fragmentation of our people and our land through policies of isolation and confiscation of land, and the building of Jewish-only settlements and the Apartheid Wall. “We are still suffering because of one political declaration from a Western empire, based on a twisted theological premise.” It made the point that some churches and some Christian leaders actually supported the establishment of a colonial state on Palestinian land, disregarding the fact that the Palestinian people had lived there for centuries and were now expected to pay a hefty price for atrocities committed in Europe. Now a third Red Alert “standing on the cliff-edge looking into an abyss”Meeting in Bethlehem last month on the 10th anniversary of their first warning document, Kairos Palestine reached out to the world’s churches yet again, saying that life in Palestine had deteriorated even further under another decade of illegal occupation.
– US recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel; – the US secretary of state’s announcement that the US government no longer deems West Bank settlements to be “inconsistent with international law”; – and the State of Israel’s recent adoption of their Nation-State Law which clearly reveals that de facto apartheid has become de jure apartheid.”
The statement went on: “There are still many who use the Bible to justify the occupation and who unquestioningly support the State of Israel. And, for the most part, the global church is failing us. We are standing as if on the edge of a cliff, looking into an abyss.” Their 2009 commitments have not changed. Sovereignty over the city of Jerusalem must be shared. They call again for us to take action and defend the rights of Palestinians and those who stand in solidarity with them, and to support all forms of creative and non-violent resistance, including BDS. We are to reject attempts to label this resistance anti-Semitic. Other points emphasised include:
“This is no time for shallow diplomacy”The essential point of their 2017 Open Letter was that time had run out: it was beyond urgent. And it ended with these chilling words: “This could be our last chance to achieve a just peace. As a Palestinian Christian community, this could be our last opportunity to save the Christian presence in this land.” So did the efforts of these Palestinian clergy, Christ’s front-line troops who daily face hostility, abuse and physical danger, finally get through to our comfy Holy Joes here? Has the penny dropped that the wellspring of their faith, the birthplace of Jesus, is being stolen and may be lost for ever if Israel gets its way? How has the World Council of Churches responded to those urgent pleas from Palestine? And did the message percolate down through the ranks? And have our spiritual leaders, those upstanding “men of the cloth”, been mobilising their troops? They promised to study and analyse. “As we at the WCC consider our plans for 2018 and beyond, we want churches in Palestine to know that their perspective is heard and it is vitally important,” said the WCC’s general secretary. “We will continue with the same passionate spirit to work on specific objectives, strategies and partners for advocacy to end the occupation and to work for just peace in Palestine and Israel.” The WCC’s Commission of the Churches on International Affairs had been asked to contribute a thorough analysis of the changing political landscapes and dynamics in the Holy Land with an eye to developing a more specific advocacy strategy that works through nations and organisations with significant influence. The WCC also planned to “explore theological reflections, studies and projects that will bring a perspective on just peace in the Holy Land from all parts of the world”, and strengthen communication about the situation in Palestine so that it can “help churches and other ecumenical partners address their constituencies and governments in a more systematic way”. This includes developing guiding principles for responsible pilgrimages of justice and peace to the Holy Land. And how is all this work coming along? Will the Palestinian churches, facing impasse and deadlock for so long, be impressed? They had pleaded: “We need brave women and men who are willing to stand in the forefront. This is no time for shallow diplomacy, Christians.” Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby’s 2019 Ecumenical Christmas Letter doesn’t mention the dire situation in Palestine or the foul conditions in Bethlehem. Nor does his Christmas Day sermon. No sense of urgency there, then. However, Colin Sinclair, Moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland had this to say: So his mind is on the job. Cardinal Vincent Nichols, Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, said: Pope Francis went as far as saying that Christmas festivities could seem a charade. These are fine words. But they tip-toe around the main issues. And where is the global action? Where is the leadership in this fightback? Will there actually be a fightback? The power of hopeChristianity sometimes has trouble telling right from wrong and doing something about it. The Holy Land is a case in point. Evil reigns there. Christianity across the world cowers. What would Christ say to that? I know what Michel Sabbah says. He is a former Catholic Patriarch of Jerusalem, a courageous man who’s on the spot and one of the great heroes of the struggle. Let’s hit the reset button!Christians who cannot grasp what is really going on out there, and who don’t understand what’s needed to stop it, might find Robert Cohen’s excellent article “Brace Yourselves for Costly Palestinian Solidarity” helpful in pointing towards proper, meaningful action. Central to the problem is the so-called Ecumenical Deal, a reluctance to question Jewish support for Israel for fear of unpicking decades of interfaith reconciliation following the holocaust. We appear to have cast ourselves in the self-defeating role of repenting for age-old Christian anti-Jewishness. Breaking out of it and criticising Israel would be seen as a re-emergence of that anti-Jewishness. Does anyone inside or outside the bubble of the church seriously buy into this repentance stuff? Besides, any re-emergence of anti-Jewishness is more likely to be caused by continuing failure on the part of Jewish leaders to condemn the cruel policies of the Israeli regime, aka “the Jewish State”, against Christian and Muslim communities. Christians in Palestine, says Cohen, despair of our church leaders’ endless hiding behind the cover of political neutrality and their unwillingness to offend their religious dialogue partners. Consequently, he predicts, Jewish-Christian dialogue “is about to go through the wringer”. And he explains why it needs resetting. Pressing the reset button means “refusing to allow your local Jewish communal leadership to set the boundaries of permissible debate on Israel”. It also means listening to the Christian voice under occupation before accepting the Jewish voice living comfortably, with full equal rights, many thousands of miles away from the Holy Land conflict zone. Operating the wringer, of course, will be followed by a distinct chill forcing church leaders, local ministers and their congregations, as well as the Jewish leaders they have dialogue with, out of their comfort zone. Good. As Rebecca Vilkomerson, Jewish Voice for Peace, wrote in Haaretz, it is time for Jewish communities “to have some really uncomfortable conversations”. Pressing the Reset button seems a useful move. PostscriptOn the morning of 30 December, on the BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, I heard the president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews say that the rise in anti-Semitism is a global disease that needs a global response. It didn’t occur to her, apparently, that much of the problem is explained by Israel’s cruel treatment of its Arab neighbours, especially the Palestinians. Wiser heads in Israel have warned for decades that Jews throughout the world would suffer for Israel’s appalling misconduct. So, it’s actually a local problem needing a local remedy. *** Share the link of this article with your facebook friends
|
|
Opinions expressed in various sections are the sole responsibility of their authors and they may not represent Al-Jazeerah & ccun.org. editor@aljazeerah.info & editor@ccun.org |